Just before Christmas, our 6 year old, Ava, lost her first tooth. While I had lots of lead time (it had been loose for a month or so), the holiday season tends to make me avoid projects unless I have to make them. Luckily though, she lost it on a Sunday, so we had time to pick a design for a tooth fairy pillow together.
Ava really like the tooth fairy character on this pillow from the Martha Stewart site, but didn't want 'just a square pillow':